An Unexpectedly Strong October Jobs Report

Image created by ChatGPT

This morning (November 6), the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) released its “Employment Situation” report (often called the “jobs report”) for October. Following September’s disappointing report, October brought better news: Payroll employment increased by 165,000, well above the 65,000 increase economists surveyed by the Wall Street Journal had forecast. The unemployment rate edged down from 4.2 percent to 4.1 percent. Revisions to earlier months also made recent job growth look stronger than previously reported.

The jobs report draws on two surveys. The establishment survey counts jobs on employers’ payrolls, while the household survey counts employed people and provides the unemployment rate. As we discuss in Macroeconomics, Chapter 9, Section 9.1 (Economics, Chapter 19, Section 19.1), the surveys cover somewhat different groups. The payroll survey generally provides a less volatile measure of monthly employment changes. The household survey supplies information about workers that payroll records cannot provide.

The BLS revised August’s payroll employment increase from 133,000 to 186,000 and September’s increase from 29,000 to 60,000. Together, those revisions added 84,000 jobs to the previously reported totals. ((The BLS notes that: “Monthly revisions result from additional reports received from businesses and government agencies since the last published estimates and from the recalculation of seasonal factors.”) With the revisions, job growth averaged 137,000 per month from August through October, compared with just 28,000 from May through July. Through October, payroll employment growth has averaged about 86,000 per month this year, compared with 10,000 per month in 2025 and 122,000 in 2024. Employment is growing faster than last year, but the average pace remains below that of 2024. The following figure from the jobs report shows the substantial monthly fluctuations in employment, as well as the stronger job growth over the past three months.

The professional and business services employment category led October’s job gains, adding 70,000. Health care added about 42,000 jobs, transportation and warehousing added about 25,000, and manufacturing added 19,000. These four groups accounted for about 94 percent of the net increase in employment. The leisure and hospitality and wholesale trade categories lost jobs. Of the overall 165,000 increase in jobs, 159,000 were in the private sector and 6,000 were in government. The following figure shows the contributions of the four leading groups and all other industries combined.

The unemployment rate, which is calculated from data in the household survey, was 4.1 percent in October, down slightly from 4.2 percent in September. The estimated size of the labor force and the number of workers employed increased in October, while the number of workers unemployed fell. The following figure shows that the unemployment rate has been remarkably stable over the past year and a half, staying between 4.0 percent and 4.4 percent in each month since June 2024. The Federal Open Market Committee’s most recent estimate of the natural rate of unemployment—the normal rate of unemployment over the long run—is 4.2 percent. So, currently the unemployment rate is slightly below that estimate of the natural rate. (We discuss the natural rate of unemployment in Macroeconomics, Chapter 9 and Economics, Chapter 19.)

As the following figure shows, the monthly net change in jobs from the household survey moves much more erratically than does the net change in jobs from the establishment survey. As measured by the household survey, there was a net increase of 463,000 jobs in October, far larger than the net increase in employment shown in the establishment survey. Since January, the household survey has shown a net increase in jobs in only four months, with a total net decrease of 377,000 jobs over the period. In contrast, the establishment survey has shown a net increase of 861,000 jobs over the same period. (Note that because of last year’s shutdown of the federal government, there are no data for October or November.)

The household survey has another important labor market indicator: the employment-population ratio for prime age workers—those workers aged 25 to 54. In October, the ratio was 80.7 percent, unchanged from September. The prime-age population ratio can show volatility from month to month but has remained above 80 percent every month since December 2022.

The establishment survey also includes data on average hourly earnings (AHE) measure of wages and salaries. The following figure shows the percentage change in AHE from the same month in the previous year. AHE increased 3.1 percent in October, down from 3.2 percent in September. That was the smallest increase since May 2021. The rate of increase in AHE has been below 4.0 percent each month since August 2025, indicating that cost pressure from wage increases has not been a significant source of price inflation during the past year. Over this same period, wage increases have struggled to keep up with price increases, resulting in a decline in real wages.

Will the strong October jobs report matter for Federal Reserve policy? At its October 27–28 meeting, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) left its target range for the federal funds rate unchanged at 3.75 percent to 4.00 percent. Inflation remains a concern: The personal consumption expenditures price index in September was up 3.6 percent from September 2025, well over the Fed’s 2 percent annual target. Today’s jobs report indicates strength in labor market, which may make Fed policymakers more willing to focus on inflation. That would increase the likelihood that the committee will raise the target for the federal funds rate at its next meeting on December 8–9.

Trading in the federal funds futures market this afternoon indicates that investors believe that the committee will increase its federal funds rate target at its December meeting. Yesterday, trading in the federal funds futures market indicated that investors assigned a 66.9 percent probably to a rate increase at the December meeting, while this afternoon the probability had increased to 79.1 percent.

How Well Are Recent College Graduates Doing in the Labor Market?

Image generated by ChatGTP-40

A number of news stories have highlighted the struggles some recent college graduates have had in finding a job. A report earlier this year by economists Jaison Abel and Richard Deitz at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York noted that: “The labor market for recent college graduates deteriorated noticeably in the first quarter of 2025. The unemployment rate jumped to 5.8 percent—the highest reading since 2021—and the underemployment rate rose sharply to 41.2 percent.”  The authors define “underemployment” as “A college graduate working in a job that typically does not require a college degree is considered underemployed.”

The following figure shows data on the unemployment rate for people ages 20 to 24 years (red line) with a bachelor’s degree, the unemployment rate for people ages 25 to 34 years (blue line) with a bachelor’s degree, and the unemployment rate for the whole population (green line) whatever their age and level of education. (Note that the values for college graduates are for those people who have a bachelor’s degree but no advanced degree, such as a Ph.D. or an M.D.)

The figure shows that unemployment rates are more volatile for both categories of college graduates than the unemployment rate for the population as a whole. The same is true for the unemployment rates for nearly any sub-category of the unemployed lagely because the number of people included the sub-categories in the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) household survey is much smaller than for the population as a whole. The figure shows that, over time, the unemployment rates for the youngest college graduates is nearly always above the unemployment rate for the population as a whole, while the unemployment rate for college graduates 25 to 34 years old is nearly always below the unemployment rate for the population as a whole. In June of this year, the unemployment rate for the population as a whole was 4.1 percent, while the unemployment for the youngest college graduates was 7.3 percent.

Why is the unemployment rate for the youngest college graduates so high? An article in the Wall Street Journal offers one explanation: “The culprit, economists say, is a general slowdown in hiring. That hasn’t really hurt people who already have jobs, because layoffs, too, have remained low, but it has made it much harder for people who don’t have work to find employment.” The following figure shows that the hiring rate—defined as the number of hires during a month divided by total employment in that month—has been falling. The hiring rate in June was 3.4 per cent, which—apart from two months at the beginning of the Covid pandemic—is the lowest rate since February 2014.

Abel and Deitz, of the New York Fed, have calculated the underemployment for new college graduates and for all college graduates. These data are shown in the following figure from the New York Fed site. The definitions used are somewhat different from the ones in the earlier figures. The definition of college graduates includes people who have advanced degrees and the definition of young college graduates includes people aged 22 years to 27 years. The data are three-month moving averages.

The data show that the underemployment rate for both recent graduates and all graduates are relatively high for the whole period shown. Typically, more than 30 percent of all college graduates and more than 40 percent of recent college graduates work in jobs in which more than 50 percent of employees don’t have college degrees. The latest underemployment rate for recent graduates is the highest since March 2022. It’s lower, though, than the rate for most of the period between the Great Recession of 2007–2009 and the Covid recession of 2020.

In a recent article, John Burn-Murdoch, a data journalist for the Financial Times, has made the point that the high unemployment rates of recent college graduates are concentrated among males. As the following figure shows, in recent months, unemployment rates among male college graduates 20 to 24 years old have been significantly higher than the unemployment rates among female college graduates. In June 2025, the unemployment rate for male recent college graduates was 9.8 percent, well above the 5.4 percent unemployment for female recent college graduates.

What explains the rise in male unemployment relative to female unemployment? Burn-Murdoch notes that, contrary to some media reports, the answer doesn’t seem to be that AI has resulted in a contraction in entry-level software coding jobs that have traditionally been held disproportionately by males. He presents data showing that “early-career coding employment is now tracking ahead of the [U.S.] economy.”

Instead he believes that the key is the continuing strong growth in healthcare jobs, which have traditionally been held disproportionately by females. The availability of these jobs has allowed women to fare better than men in an economy in which hiring rates have been relatively low.

Like most short-run trends, it’s possible that the relatively high unemployment rates experienced by recent college graduates may not continue in the long run.